Find top-rated realtors in Mashpee, MA. Compare experienced local agents to buy or sell your home with expert knowledge of the Cape Cod market.

The best real estate agents in Mashpee, MA: sales data and client reviews

You may be looking for a real estate agent in Mashpee, Massachusetts. You likely want one familiar enough with Cape Cod to help you find the right home, be it a waterfront property in New Seabury or something simpler closer to downtown.

When you take a look at Zillow reviews, Yelp ratings, and sales data on realestateandhomes.com, several names pop up frequently. Our own Livia Monteforte and the Freitas Monteforte Group at Compass are among the highest-rated agents (with 110+ reviews) and among the most active (we close high volume across Cape Cod, with plenty of those in Mashpee).

John Bowen runs Bowen Real Estate of Cape Cod and holds a 5.0-star rating on Zillow, with approximately 30 sales in the Mashpee area. Over at Keller Williams, Kathleen Conway does a strong volume of local sales, and Serena LoPiccolo-Smith gets constantly praised for being both professional and responsive to clients' needs.

Then there's Carli Taylor at Compass, who made the 2025 RealTrends Verified list as a top Mashpee agent.

Agent/Team	Brokerage	Reviews	Mashpee Volume	What They Do
Livia Monteforte / Freitas Monteforte Group	Compass	110+	High (Cape-wide)	Coastal, waterfront, luxury
John Bowen	Bowen Real Estate of Cape Cod	5.0 stars	~30 sales	Mashpee specialist
Kathleen Conway	Keller Williams	Strong	High locally	Full-service
Carli Taylor	Compass	RealTrends list	Top recent	Mashpee focus
Serena LoPiccolo-Smith	Keller Williams	Praised	Solid	Professional, communicative

Each agent uses a different method to address the Mashpee market. Some stay hyper-focused on Mashpee and New Seabury, while others (like the Freitas Monteforte Group) serve the entire Cape, giving them context on how Mashpee fits into the broader regional picture.

That broader context becomes important when evaluating whether you're receiving good value for your money.

What to look for when picking a Mashpee agent

The highest number of sales in the past 12 months doesn't guarantee you've found the best agent. What actually matters? Finding someone whose skills align with the services you need for your purchase or sale.

Test their neighborhood knowledge

Ask specific questions about Willowbend, South Cape Beach, or streets like Mashpee Neck Rd. Ask what types of properties have sold recently (2-bedroom condos versus 4-bedroom single-family homes) and how long these properties sat on the market before selling.

Great agents give you details. Bad agents give you generalities.

Test responsiveness early

Homes go under contract quickly in today's Mashpee real estate environment, so you need an agent who responds promptly to inquiries about properties for sale. An agent who takes a full day to get back to you might cost you the house you want.

Review testimonials on Yelp and Zillow to confirm an agent is responsive ("I was able to communicate with my agent easily"), knowledgeable ("my agent had a thorough understanding of the area"), and professional ("my agent acted with the utmost professionalism").

Technology matters now in ways it didn't five years ago

The best teams use search platforms that let you access detailed property information (square footage, number of bathrooms, price range, amenities) quickly and efficiently. The Freitas Monteforte Group developed its business model to combine advanced technology with boots-on-the-ground Cape Cod knowledge, so you get rapid responses without losing local expertise.

Most people fixate on credentials and overlook a bigger factor.

How Cape Cod market experience can help you purchase a home in Mashpee

Experience working in Mashpee specifically matters. But agents who work across Cape Cod generally provide valuable insights that hyper-local experts sometimes lack.

These agents possess a deeper understanding of the regulatory environment affecting property values along the Massachusetts coast. They recognize seasonal fluctuations in the marketplace (summer versus winter inventory levels, tourist rental potential) and understand how Mashpee pricing compares to nearby municipalities.

This gives you flexibility when considering alternative locations. Maybe you'd get better value 10 miles away. Or maybe the data confirms that Mashpee is exactly where you should be.

Consider the Freitas Monteforte Group

Livia Monteforte has been a licensed real estate broker on Cape Cod for over 20 years, and our Compass team specializes in coastal, luxury, and waterfront properties throughout the Cape. We do significant business in Mashpee but also operate in Falmouth, Barnstable, and other Cape communities.

So if you're searching for a 3-bathroom waterfront home, we can tell you whether the price compares well to similar properties or whether you'd be better served by purchasing in another community.

We started as Freitas Realty Group in 2005, went through a NextHome phase, then joined Compass to expand our reach nationally and improve our technology. Because of our history, we've weathered multiple real estate cycles and developed relationships with the mortgage brokers, inspectors, and contractors you'll need during the transaction.

That kind of depth only comes from sticking around.

Once you complete your research, the decision typically comes down to fit.

Property type and work style: the two most important factors

Property type alignment

Property type alignment usually resolves any remaining questions. If you're searching for a luxury waterfront home (over 2,500 square feet, with 4+ bathrooms, and water views), you want an agent who regularly deals with that segment, not someone whose bread and butter is modest condominiums and units.

The reverse applies just as much.

Your timeline and communication preferences

Your timeline and communication preferences also matter. Some buyers want every new listing forwarded the minute it hits the market. Others want curated picks based on tight criteria.

Neither approach is wrong, but the agent's style should match yours.

For sellers: examine how the agent markets other listings

Were the photographs professional quality? Did the listing description contain useful property details, or just generic fluff? Did the agent price the property based on actual comparable sales, or just hope for the best?

Good marketing sells homes faster and for better prices.

Work with the Freitas Monteforte Group

The Freitas Monteforte Group combines 20+ years of experience representing clients in Cape Cod real estate transactions with the global platform and technology of Compass. We handle Mashpee's coastal and waterfront properties (luxury estates, investment condominiums, everything in between).

If you're ready to purchase or sell a home in Mashpee, MA, contact us. We'll help you identify your needs and achieve your goals.

Contact Us Today