Buying on Cape Cod for the first time is a different kind of stress than buying almost anywhere else in Massachusetts. Inventory is tight, offers move fast, and the regulations around coastal properties alone can derail a deal if your agent isn't ahead of them.
And the names below keep coming up for a reason when people begin their hunt for their first home.
Top-rated agents and teams for first-time buyers
When first-time buyers on the Cape describe agents who actually walked them through the process rather than just closed a deal, these are the ones they mention.
| Agent / Team | Brokerage | Best For |
|---|---|---|
| Freitas Monteforte Group | Compass | Coastal homes, Cape-wide, tech-forward process |
| Melanie Gundersheim | Gundersheim Group | Patient, thorough guidance (5.0 stars) |
| Buyers Brokers Only | Independent | Exclusive buyer representation |
| Bob Churchill | Buyer Brokers of Cape Cod | Complex Cape transactions |
| Jessica Krikorian | Classic Cape RE | First-time buyer education, local native |
| Melanie Cauchon | My Cape Cod Realty | Remote buyers, detailed communication |
Where Cape Cod tends to catch first-time buyers off guard
Barnstable prices differently than Brewster. Chatham moves faster than both.
But here's the thing: beyond town-by-town variation, coastal properties here come with Title V septic requirements and flood zone classifications that hit your insurance costs and financing in ways buyers rarely anticipate until they're already under agreement.
Spring brings more listings but also more competition. Fall is quieter, sometimes significantly so.
Which is why a good agent flags all of this in the first conversation, not during the final walkthrough.
Solo agent or team: the practical difference
Knowing what actually separates your options makes this choice easier.
Availability: Teams distribute coverage across hours and days; a solo agent is one person's calendar.
Systems: Tech-forward teams (the Freitas Monteforte Group runs on Compass infrastructure) give remote buyers real-time document access and fewer moments of radio silence.
Reach: Solo agents often go deep on specific towns; teams tend to cover the Cape more broadly.
Fit: How fast someone responds to your first inquiry tells you most of what you need to know.
One question worth asking every agent you talk to: How many first-time buyers did you represent in the past year?
The ones who do it consistently answer without hesitation. Others start talking about their total transaction volume instead.
Work with Livia and the Freitas Monteforte Group
Livia Monteforte founded her Cape Cod real estate practice in 2005 and has been running the Freitas Monteforte Group at Compass ever since, focusing specifically on coastal and luxury properties across the Cape. The team is built for buyers who want real communication, not status-update emails every few weeks.
If you're buying in Falmouth, along the coast, or anywhere on the Cape and want a team that's done this long enough to have seen most of what can go wrong, reach out today.
Contact Us Today
